How to Hire a Home Improvement Contractor Without Getting Burned
Published
The difference between a good contracting experience and a bad one is usually decided before the first day of work, in the estimate and the contract. Here is what to check, in order.
- Proof of insurance. Ask for a certificate of liability insurance and confirm it is current. Workers' compensation coverage matters too: if the contractor's crew is not covered and someone is hurt on your property, the claim can land on your policy.
- Licensing where it applies. Requirements differ by state and county, and some trades are not licensed at all. Ask what license or certification the trade requires and verify it directly with the issuing body rather than taking the company's word for it.
- A written estimate with quantities. A real estimate states what material, how much, at what price, and what is and is not included. A single lump sum with no detail is not an estimate; it is a starting point for a change order.
- Three references you can actually reach. Ask for jobs of similar scope, not just the biggest ones. Call the homeowners.
- Payment terms that protect you. A reasonable structure is a deposit at signing, progress payments tied to completed stages, and the balance on completion. A contractor asking for most of the money up front, or full payment before work starts, is telling you something.
- Permits. Who pulls the permits? For most structural, electrical, plumbing and HVAC work, permits are required and the homeowner is responsible for final approval. Find out up front, and ask to see the inspection record when the job is done.
- Insurance on the work. Confirm the contractor carries coverage that applies to completed work, and get a warranty in writing that names who is responsible if the work fails.
Watch for the most common pricing trap: a low estimate followed by change orders. The defense is a scope of work in writing that lists what is included and what is excluded, plus a clear statement of how change orders will be priced and approved before work proceeds. Nothing should be added to your bill without your written agreement first.
One more thing: do not pay everything upfront, and do not pay in full before a final inspection and a walkthrough. Holding a portion until the work is complete and the punch list is closed is standard practice, not adversarial.
If a contractor pressures you to decide today, rushes you past a written scope, or will not let you speak with previous customers, that is information. Walk away.
Before requesting a quote, compare the visible damage with the signs of masonry deterioration or review what a chimney sweep quote should include, depending on the work you need.
- contractor
- estimates
- permits